Eddie and Sasha's thread only has 30 tags. This would net you 20 points + 20 points for the new CR (40). If you're also taking the tag-in to a PC-started log, that's an additional 10 points (50). If you've already used that bonus, then you're short by 5 points. Please just specify if you were taking into account the tag-in bonus.

Your second link leads to the entire message board. Could you please link to the specific thread or threads you're drawing from?