Item: A fancy telescope delivered to Natalie
Points used: 50
Log post and 20+ comments (45)
An additional 10 comments from this thread with Ammond atop what was there before (5)

Item: A book on astronomy delivered to Natalie
Points used: 50
40+ comments with The Disciple (25)
40+ comments with Eddie, Mika, and Ammond (25)

Item: A star chart for their new world's stars delivered to Natalie
Points used: 50
Log post (30)
30+ comments with Ienzo and Jay (20)

Item: The 'guttersnipe' hat that Sasha had as a kid delivered to Sasha with a note saying 'Merry Christmas.'
Points used: 50
First interaction with Sasha and 20+ comments (35)
20+ comments with Ammond (15)

Item: Not exactly an item, but that Bertie's wings appear/disappear at-will like Eddie's.
Points used: 200
First interaction with Lili (20)
First interaction with Riku and 10+ comments (30)
First interaction with Aeleus and 20+ comments (35)
30+ comments with Ienzo (20)
10+ comments with Eddie (10)
30+ comments with Jay (20)
30+ comments with Sasha (20)
60+ comments with Eddie, Ammond, and Ienzo (35)
10+ comments with the Disciple and Jay (10)